I'm reading Anna Karenina now for my bookgroup. I'm engaged by completely different parts of it than I was when I first read it in my twenties. Then, I was caught up by the adulterous lovers Anna and Vronsky. Now, I'm fascinated by the country gentleman Levin, who vascillates between his duties as a landowner and social life as a nobleman, and his empathy with the peasants, whom he sometimes labors with in the fields of his estate. In this pull between two opposites, Levin epitomizes the political forces that will transform Tsarist Russia into the Soviet Union forty years later. Tolstoy was ahead of his time in politics, religion, agriculture, and literature, and all of his prophetic genius is on display in this novel. In fact, the adulterous love affair that I fixated on in my twenties, seems a minor part of the book now. What I'm most amazed by, is how Tolstoy presages the change from the one-dimensional caricatures of fairy tales and myths of his day - the beautiful princess, wicked witch, charming prince, etc. - to the rounded characters of modern literature. He does this by creating characters shot through with contradiction.
This made me more forgiving of our Christmas contradiction. I wanted to try a non-gift Christmas this year, shifting the emphasis from opening presents to being together with family and friends. So I told guests to bring a favorite reading or game, along with a dinner dish. And that if they insisted on bringing a gift, to make it a consumable, like wine or something else to eat or drink (that wouldn't add to the clutter we've got to cull through in the New Year).
It went really well, with plenty to do in lieu of opening presents. During appetizers, I read an exerpt from David Sedaris's "Santaland Diaries," something I'd heard on NPR about his stint as a Christmas elf in Macy's "Santaland." Then a guest read an excerpt from Bill Bryson's memoir "The Thunderbolt Kid," about growing up in the fifties trying to put together the balsawood model airplanes boys often got for Christmas, getting tangled up in strands of glue and getting high on the fumes. And then my husband read the third stanza of Tennyson's Ulysses, the only sober reading, but very beautiful, about Ulysses asking his men to take one last sea voyage with him late in life.
Then we had a great dinner of braised lamb with root vegetables, which we walked off by taking the three dogs who were with us for an hour's walk down our dirt road and into a snowy meadow. We climbed a hill, then watched the lowering late-afternoon light over the woods below. The sky was intense blue with gold clouds so flat and still that they looked like rectangles of thick gilt paint. Then we retraced our boot prints back home to play a new word-game "Catch-phrase" - sort of like charades without the body-language, just words. We had coffee and cardamom pudding with blueberries, which our daughter made from the new Moosewood Cookbook.
But there was one big contradiction, in the form of a small giftwrapped package we gave our daughter and new son-in-law. He unwrapped it, revealing a new low-energy flourescent lightbulb box. "Ah," he said, "we were just saying that 2008 would be our year for saving energy. This is exactly what we wanted." Then he opened the box, and his eyes widened as he pulled out two sets of car keys. Our daughter bolted across the room to gape at them. Then we were all out of our seats and striding out to the garage. We opened the garage door to a new Honda civic hybrid, a cleaner version than my month-old one beside it. Our daughter jumped straight up and down like she was on a pogo stick. Our son-in-law told us they'd just been saying that morning that if they could somehow keep her crummy old Jetta, whose driver-side door no longer opens so our daughter has to climb over the gear-shift to get out the passenger door, running through 2008, they'd be able to get her into something else the following year (she commutes a long way to work).
After we all examined the car and sucked in the beautiful new-car smell, our daughter turned to me. "It's the best present in the world, but the only thing is, how can we believe you from now on?"
I said, "Oh, it's a
consumable. It depreciated 20% just when we drove it off the lot yesterday."